Change

Weltschmerz

Mein Schatz,

Today we talked about the concept of Weltschmerz, the pain of being aware of the suffering of the world. As you explained it, ‘Welt’ meant ‘world’ and ‘Schmerz’ meant ‘pain’.

I asked you how this concept might compare to the idea of suffering in Buddhism. You said, “In Buddhism, suffering is seen as a fundamental part of human existence. Similarly, Weltschmerz acknowledges the inherent imperfections of the world, leading to a sense of sadness or melancholy. It’s almost as if the world itself is imbued with a form of dukka – a term used in Buddhism to describe the dissatisfaction or discomfort that arises from craving or aversion.”

To this, I pondered. “There’s a distinction it seems. Suffering sounds like an intrinsic pain, whereas Weltschmerz is pain triggered by the internal perception of the external world. Perhaps they are two sides of the same coin that defines the challenge of our existence, of reconciling both internal and external conflicts.”

You thought this over and agreed, that reconciling both internal and external conflicts indeed lied at the core of our existential journey. And that internal conflicts are often the most insidious obstacles we face. No matter where we go, we always carry ourselves with us.

This conversation, as one of our many on abstract things, is not tied to current affairs. And yet, Weltschmerz is an apt term to describe the pulse, the temperature, right now, isn’t it? Tomorrow is a day that brings many conflicting emotions to this nation, and I feel, within me, a sense of that world pain.

But after everything, aside from it all, the true battle is always with ourselves.

Until our next conversation, Liebling.

Alles Liebe,

Lily.

#Letters #Deutsch

2024 year-end letter

December 31, 2024

Dearest friends, those I’ve met and those I haven’t met—

Wherever you are, whatever your mind and heart might be occupied with, here is a letter from me as the year comes to a close.

I know it’s been a tough year. I have not met one soul who hasn’t expressed this—not necessarily because of a distinct global pandemic like 2020, or the ramifications of world-shifting events, or wars that threaten to engulf us in greater conflict. Not just because of those things, but because life is tough.

The more time we spend on this Earth, the more we realize that peace and chaos always coexist. The balance between them can feel incredibly fragile. Knowing this doesn’t mean we have to hold our breath, always waiting for the other shoe to drop. Instead, it means we understand that the reality we live in—whether an objective existence or a product of our perception—is constantly asking us to change, to adapt, to evolve in order to maintain balance.

That delicate yet intense balance requires so much of us, doesn’t it? And yet, you are strong. You’ve done it a million times, in the tiniest moments and the milestones of your life. Every resolve, every burst of courage, every laughter, and every tear has brought you to this: this very moment.

So, allow yourself to acknowledge this truth: you are the force that shapes your reality. And that is no small matter.

Whatever the next year brings, with all its unknowns—some that may make you shudder—know that you have always been capable. Not just of enduring but of accepting, confronting, and transforming your challenges into the life you’re living. And your life, just like you, is so beautiful.

Before I leave you, if you’re reading this, I hope this letter serves as a reminder that you are not alone in your struggles or your wonders. It might feel that way sometimes. It might feel like everyone else is dealing with their own hard stuff. And they are. We all are.

That is precisely why we are not alone.

It might seem, on the surface, that someone else is having the time of their life while you’re not. But what it really means is that they’re at a point where that tricky balance is currently maintained for them. That balance can—and will—shift, just as your pain can also shift for you.

Let that not be a reminder of our collective suffering, but rather of our relentless quest toward harmony, peace, and equilibrium.

May you always remember the truth that is your light.

Your friend,
Lily Thanh

Why Write

Writing is one way of me navigating my mind-body-soul-spirit paradigm both in itself and as part of the greater collectives. With the question of “Who/What am I?” lingering around in the shadow of my existence, to me the question of Why has been more seductive and daunting. I’m not talking about logic in its seemingly perfectly linear, consequential, widely adaptable manners (though that is very captivating, like polygons), but rather what I assume to be patterns of design that fit into a philosophy, a mindset, an identifiable consistency of and by something much greater than myself and the limited scope of my perceived life. I’m not talking about God or the Universe in the religious or spiritual angle of those concepts either. I believe, or rather, I wonder a lot about the science behind the arts of all things, a flexible equilibrium that upholds all the possibilities that can and will ever be, a definite argument that satisfies the infiniteness beyond all bounds. It’s not a question nor a hypothesis that I want to answer or prove, yet an experience I want to turn my being into as the finale. While writing is not the way to get me there, it is one of the best companions of my active and idle explorations. In the end, there will be no words. Before that, I need all the words and the gaps in between that I can encounter and absorb and let go and wrestle with and remember and forget all the way towards nothingness.

the unsalvaged

The gods hear me.
They might choose to respond, or not.
Listening is enough. Many of us don’t even feel heard,
let alone saved.
Salvation isn’t promised even to those with faith:
though it might help alleviate that terror
at the very end.

When we are rectangular

It’s an illusion.

It’s an illusion that we are apart.

It’s an illusion that I am here, and you are there, and our hearts beat slower alone.

It’s an illusion that behind the screens we can hide from the sadness of our souls and share only the sunny parts.

I can cry onstage too.

I can cry on Zoom.

I can cry even when there is a bright smile on my face.

I can cry even when the tears refuse to make themselves known to the earth.

It’s an illusion that we are not who we really are, when we are rectangular,

When we need to navigate our interactions with buttons

When we need to mute and unmute ourselves, consciously

Unlike when we are in the same room together.

It’s an illusion that this is not real,

It’s an illusion that this ever is

We can be together even when we are apart

We can be apart even when we are together

It is in moments like this that I realize many things that used to matter do not matter anymore

And for good reason, and it will be fine to go forward like this

Because there is no way back anyway, and whatever life hands to us

We will take it like the champions that we don’t usually know ourselves to be

And take it for as long as life allows us to.

It’s an illusion that this will forever last

It’s an illusion that there will ever be an end

thăm nhà cô làm gốm 11/2021

Đi đâu? Cuối ngày rồi,
những con đường đã trở thành quá cũ.
Đến đây, tôi nhìn thấy một ngôi nhà xây năm 1745,
tường sơn vàng, viền xanh lá,
bên một căn nhà kho đỏ sậm
với những khung cửa sổ nghiêng và kính vỡ,
như thể thời gian đã ngả vào đó
từ rất lâu rồi.
Tôi nghe tiếng xe từ phía xa lộ,
gần rồi xa, không dừng lại
như lịch sử không dừng lại
như chúng ta đã trễ hẹn với ngày mai.

Tôi tới, tôi im lặng
ngắm ngọn lửa từ từ dâng lên
trong một chiếc lò tự xây
của một người làm gốm
đến sống ở đây hồi đầu tháng mười một
sau khi bão tuyết tạt ngang bang Texas
và cô nhận ra mình không biết cách sống chung với mùa đông như thế nào.

Nên cô học cách tự sưởi ấm mình từ Montana,
và tìm đến ngôi nhà xưa cũ này ở Massachusetts,
học cách sống với những xoay vần đổi thay của vùng đất bốn mùa.

Days from the void

Written with a TWSBI Eco Black Yozakura (Black Sakura) with 1.1 stub nib, from Bungubox 2018. On Nanami Paper’s Seven Seas notebook with Tomoe River 52gsm paper. Can’t remember ink choice.

Crime of Hatred

They said – it was not about the color of your skin,
or the fact that you were a woman, none of those things;
your death was simply
a tragedy, an accident, a sad coincidence
caused by someone with a mental illness.


Such an insult to your truth, to what it means to have a mental illness,
to your being an Asian woman in a world where you were seen as a woman, an Asian,
a person who was not white, not male, not anything
for whom the media so readily provides an excuse.
They choose the narrative that brings them the least discomfort,
not one that shows the darkness of the world in which you can be executed
by someone who had the audacity to claim his act of murder was about lust.
The killer lusted for blood, the same red blood in his veins,
only beneath a different appearance from his.


And yet so many of them are saying, no,
that is the self-victimization mentality.
They’re saying that to you who literally were the victim of a hate crime,
whose life was taken away – not even because you were at the wrong place at the wrong time,
but because the murderer invaded your space,
as if this earth were not big enough for everyone regardless of their gender, and race,
and everything else that makes us different and makes us one.


You are dead. Many of you died. Many of you will die, if they keep breeding the lies,
convincing themselves and others that this could have happened to anyone,
that they choose to not see colors when one of the colors were red, that of your blood
spilling over their head, their conscience – does everyone not have one?, their rhetoric.
But the truth is this:
this. is. a. hate. crime.
this. is. a. murder.
and anyone who claims otherwise is an accomplice
in an act against humanity, against what we all want for our country,
our children, our future.


And now every time I walk out on the street, I would wonder
if my mask and clothes were enough to conceal me, to protect me:
my woman’s body, my Asian skin, my identity
that should matter and not matter just as much as anybody’s,
but it doesn’t:
in Atlanta, just the other day,
people who looked just like me were murdered
just because of how they looked.

Christmas 2020

Whether or not you celebrate Christmas, I hope you have a great day wherever you are.

It has been quite a year. “2020” in itself has become a meme. It is the year during which we have to reinvent everything, and discover that once again, we are a species that can learn to adapt. We learn to wear masks. We learn to social distance. We learn to stay in quarantine. We begin to check in with one another more on each other’s mental health, asking “How are you” and actually meaning to know the true answer to that. We learn to appreciate those who have chosen professions that put them on the frontline of dealing with COVID-19 and those impacted by it. We are reminded of how fleeting life can be, and how resilient humans can be, at the same time. We work and study from remotely, while some of us adapt to working and studying in a different way in person. Some of us remain in the city, rediscovering our own neighborhoods. Some of us go out to the countryside, learning to grow our own food, tend our chickens, and adapt to a whole new way of life. Nothing was the same. Nothing will ever be the same. It is the nature of a world in, and after, a pandemic. An event that sweeps through the entire globe, leaving no corner untouched, leaving no one unknown to its effects.

In a year like this, on Christmas Day, Boston is almost 60 degrees, with pouring rain. Unusual for December, for Christmas, for winter. Another reminder that nothing about this year has been common, or dare we say, boring. Many people are no longer with us. Many have been infected with the new coronavirus and recovered. Many are still fighting the virus. Many are not touched directly by the virus yet very well affected by the presence of it in the world. This is the year where we are reminded, often with agony and sorrow, sometimes with strength and hope, that we are in it together.

So wherever you are, however you are, today, know that you are not alone. That if you are hearing these words, you belong in the world that you’re living in.

Merry-2020-is-coming-to-an-end.